SET Fall 2025 – Building an Inclusive Higher Education Community for Low-Income Students: Research & Practice
views
comments
Policy
This service is for academic use only. Please go here for more information on Baylor's Kaltura guidelines and video retention notice.
Description of an Academic Seminar on Supporting Low-Income Students
This document summarizes a university seminar focused on understanding the experiences of low-income students in higher education and providing practical strategies for instructors to support them. The session was hosted by a graduate fellow from the institution's Academy for Teaching and Learning.
The presentation was led by two researchers: an assistant professor of higher education studies and a fourth-year doctoral candidate from the same program.
Presentation Summary- Introduction & Context:
- The presenters framed the discussion by noting that higher education was historically designed by and for wealthy elites. While demographics have changed, many institutional structures (like the high cost of fraternities/sororities or study abroad) remain, which can be exclusionary.
- A brief overview of financial aid was provided (loans, grants, merit aid), with a specific focus on "Promise Programs." These programs aim to offset the "sticker shock" of college by guaranteeing low-cost tuition for eligible students.
- The Research Study:
- The presentation detailed a multi-year, qualitative study on students at the university who receive a specific "last dollar" promise program.
- This program functions like "icing on a cake": after all federal, state, and other institutional aid is applied, the university's grant covers any remaining balance for tuition and fees.
- Methods: The study uses focused ethnographic methods, including interviews, focus groups, and "Financial Diaries," which are weekly surveys tracking student income, expenditures, and financial stressors.
- Key Findings:
- Highly Scheduled: Students are extremely busy, with one describing their schedule as "the most colorful color coded thing you'll ever see."
- High-Achieving & Aspirational: Many students are pre-med, pre-law, or in other demanding programs. They view college as a job and aim to graduate early, often arriving with significant dual-credit hours.
- Financially Stressed & Debt-Averse: Despite the tuition grant, students are highly stressed about other costs (housing, food, books) and are deeply "debt-averse," avoiding loans at all costs.
- Small Expenses Matter: Supplementary course materials not covered by aid (like online platforms such as Top Hat or Achieve, or clickers) are a significant source of financial stress, as students must pay for them out-of-pocket.
- Faculty Relationships: Students were highly complimentary of faculty who showed personal care and investment in their lives, such as by inviting students to dinner.
- Practical Recommendations for Instructors:
- Be Mindful of Costs: Recognize that students are debt-averse and that small fees for online programs are not covered by aid.
- Rethink Materials: Consider using Open Educational Resources (OER), textbook rental options, or placing a personal desk copy of expensive books on reserve at the library.
- Assume Good Intentions: Students are managing intense schedules with work, family, and high-commitment organizations (like band). A lack of participation in office hours or tutoring may be due to time scarcity, not a lack of care.
- Be Flexible: Consider soliciting student opinions on convenient times for office hours.
- Financial Literacy: The researchers noted that these students are, contrary to some literature, highly financially literate. They discussed opening Roth IRAs and managing high-yield savings accounts to pay for expenses.
- The "Vibe" of Wealth: Students are highly sensitive to campus wealth markers (e.g., "Lululemon girls," "G-Wagons," "Stanley" water bottles). They reported using meal plan "swipes" at the campus Starbucks as a way to "fit in" with the social culture.
- The Aid System: A related paper from the research team explores the "dehumanization of financial aid," arguing that the system itself (not individual staff members) strips students down to numbers and can be traumatizing.
- Roommate Selection: An interesting cultural detail emerged: many students find roommates not through the university but through unofficial, paid Instagram pages where they can post profiles.
- Tags
-